During my first pregnancy, when my husband and I sat down to hash out names, it came easily. My husband said a name, I agreed. We were done.
Well we would have been done, if we were having a boy. But my husband loves to wait to find out the gender, so we didn’t know if we were having a boy or a girl until the delivery.
And with the girl’s name? Well, that took time. And by “time”, I mean we were basically throwing knives at each other the whole nine months. We went to the hospital with one boy name and two girl names. And for the next four hours after we heard, “It’s a girl!” We were stymied. Finally, when I saw the nurses writing “baby girl Lenz” on the door sign, I began to sob: “THAT’S NOT HER NAME!”
I gave in and told my husband to pick. And perhaps out of fear, or kindness, or because he saw that our child was an Ellis, he went with the name I had chosen, he went with Ellis. It’s a name we both love and love more and more as our daughter grows into it. I choose it because it was the pen name of one of my favorite authors, Emily Bronte, who wrote as Ellis Bell. Also, my mother is Ellen Claire, I am Elizabeth Claire. I loved carrying down that naming convention to my daughter: Ellis Claire.
Now we are here again: At loggerheads over a girl’s name.
I wanted to start with a fresh list. My husband just wanted to go with the second choice from before. But I firmly believe each of our children should have their own names. Not someone else’s leftovers. Which is noble, but it’s making picking a girl’s name this time around excruciating.
What also makes it harder is that we have different taste. Dave is more classical and I am, well, weird. Here is how baby naming conversations happen.
Me: How about Avalon? Nickname, Ava.
Dave: You’ve been watching too much science fiction. Nerd. How about Sherlock or Mycroft?
Me: Mycroft isn’t so bad.
Dave: I WAS KIDDING!
And so it’s been going for 25 weeks.
In all fairness, this is us. We are not quick decision makers. It took us two years to pick out bedroom furniture and a whole year to pick out a couch. Compromise comes slowly, simply because we don’t compromise. We work to make both of us happy. But we are running out of time. By this point in my last pregnancy, we had already come up with Ellis and The Other Name and it was just a matter of toying with nicknames.
This time, we have nothing. Just a list of rejected names. I love all of these names, but for one reason or another, they don’t work for our family. I am sharing them with you since they are no longer in the running. If they inspire any name suggestions, please let me know.
Eden: I love this name. It has a lovely nickname, Edie. And also the name makes reference to my favorite Steinbeck novel, East of Eden.
Zelda: Zelda Fitzgerald was a beautiful, intelligent and tragic woman and her name is gorgeous.
Fable: Evokes tales of old and beautiful stories.
Nova: I love the reference to the stars.
Louisa: Louisa Mae Alcott was a pioneer and a feminist, before such a thing existed. I love her.
Ellery: Ellery Queen was a fictional character and the name of a crime magazine that has published some of the best American mystery writers of all time. Also, it’s a lovely name.
Ember: I love that the name evokes smoldering fire.
Quincy: Our child will be born in early July, so I love the idea of giving her (or him) a name that has significance for our country. John Quincy Adams was a wonderful man and one of my favorite characters from history.
Lincoln: Another great name and a great American.
Felicity: A name that means great happiness and bliss. What could be better?
What are your favorite girls’ names?